Did the parties switch?

Yes. The party realignment was gradual, spanning from 1948 through the 1980s. It began with Thurmond's Dixiecrat campaign in 1948, accelerated when Goldwater opposed the Civil Rights Act in 1964, was exploited by Nixon's Southern Strategy in 1968, and solidified under Reagan in 1980. In 2005, RNC Chairman Ken Mehlman formally apologized for the Southern Strategy.

Who started the Civil War?

Confederate forces fired the first shots at Fort Sumter at 4:30 AM on April 12, 1861. The Union garrison had not fired a shot. The Confederate states seceded and attacked federal property to preserve slavery, as explicitly stated in their own secession declarations.

Why did Southern states secede?

The seceding states explicitly cited slavery as the cause. Mississippi's declaration states: 'Our position is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery—the greatest material interest of the world.' Georgia's declaration mentions slavery over 80 times. Tariffs are rarely or never mentioned in these documents.

What was the Southern Strategy?

The Southern Strategy was a Republican electoral strategy to win white Southern voters by appealing to racial resentment. Nixon adviser Kevin Phillips outlined it in 1970. Lee Atwater later explained how it evolved from explicit racism to coded language like 'states' rights' and 'forced busing.' RNC Chairman Ken Mehlman apologized for it in 2005.

Didn't more Republicans vote for the Civil Rights Act?

Yes, but this is misleading. The real divide was regional, not partisan: Northern Democrats voted 94% yes, while Southern Democrats voted only 7% yes. It was North vs South, not Republican vs Democrat. And those Southern Democrats who opposed civil rights? Their voters became Republicans over the following decades, which is exactly what the party switch describes.

What about Robert Byrd?

Robert Byrd joined the KKK in the 1940s, but spent 50 years apologizing for it. He called it 'the greatest mistake I ever made,' voted for the Civil Rights Act of 1968, and supported renewing the Voting Rights Act. The NAACP praised him at his death in 2010. More importantly, the party switch was about voters, not individual politicians. The white South moved from Democratic to Republican; that's the switch.

Reconstruction

Reconstruction failed not because equality was impossible, but because America chose not to enforce it. Radical Republicans proposed a comprehensive program of accountability that, if enacted, might have prevented 150 years of racial terror. Here's what they demanded, and what we got instead.

The Men Who Tried

The Radical Republicans

They demanded accountability. They were ignored. History proved them right.

The most powerful Radical Republican in Congress. Stevens demanded land redistribution, treason trials for Confederate leaders, and full citizenship for freed people. He called Andrew Johnson a traitor and led his impeachment. He died before seeing his vision realized, and America is still paying for ignoring him.

What He Demanded:

Confiscate Confederate plantations and redistribute land to freed people
Try Confederate leaders for treason
Full voting rights and citizenship for Black Americans
Federal enforcement of civil rights in the South
Permanent exclusion of Confederate leaders from office

What He Said:

""

What Happened:

Johnson pardoned Confederate leaders. Land was returned to slaveholders. Freed people got nothing.

""

The Senate's leading voice for abolition and civil rights. In 1856, a pro-slavery congressman nearly beat him to death on the Senate floor for an anti-slavery speech. Sumner spent three years recovering, then returned to lead the fight for the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments. He died still fighting for civil rights legislation.

What He Demanded:

Complete civil and political equality for Black Americans
Desegregation of schools, transportation, and public accommodations
Federal civil rights enforcement
Opposition to any compromise with former Confederates

What He Said:

""

What Happened:

Sumner's Civil Rights Act of 1875 was gutted by the Supreme Court in 1883. It took until 1964 for Congress to pass similar legislation.

""

A Union general who declared escaped slaves 'contraband of war,' refusing to return them to Confederate owners, creating the policy that led to emancipation. As a congressman, he drafted the Ku Klux Klan Act and led the impeachment prosecution of Andrew Johnson.

What He Demanded:

Refuse to return escaped slaves to Confederate owners (contraband policy)
Federal prosecution of Klan terrorism
Impeachment of Andrew Johnson
Military occupation until civil rights were guaranteed

What He Said:

""

What Happened:

Butler's Klan Act was weakened by the Supreme Court. Johnson's impeachment failed by one vote. Federal enforcement ended in 1877.

""

A minister and educator who became the first African American to serve in the U.S. Senate, filling the seat once held by Jefferson Davis. Revels proved that Black Americans could govern, which is exactly why white supremacists worked so hard to ensure it never happened again.

What He Demanded:

Full citizenship and voting rights for Black Americans
Desegregation of federal workforce
Amnesty for some ex-Confederates (controversial among Radicals)
Education as the path to equality

What He Said:

""

What Happened:

Within a decade, Mississippi's 1890 constitution stripped Black citizens of the vote Revels had exercised. No Black senator from the South for 130 years.

""

The Road Not Taken

What Should Have Happened

Six measures that could have prevented 150 years of racial terror. Every one was blocked or abandoned.

The Proposal:

Confederate leaders committed treason, the only crime defined in the Constitution. They should have been tried, and the guilty executed or imprisoned. This would have prevented them from returning to power and rewriting history.

What Actually Happened:

Andrew Johnson pardoned over 13,000 Confederate officials. Jefferson Davis was indicted but never tried. No Confederate leader was executed for treason. Most returned to power within years.

The Consequence:

The men who led the rebellion lived to found the Lost Cause mythology, lead Redemption governments, and pass Jim Crow laws. Every Confederate monument was placed by someone who should have been in prison.

The Comparison:

After World War II, Nazi leaders faced the Nuremberg Trials. Germany was denazified. Confederate leaders faced nothing.

The Proposal:

Confiscate Confederate plantations and redistribute them to freed people. Give every freedman 40 acres of land and the means to work it. Economic independence is the foundation of political freedom.

What Actually Happened:

Sherman's Special Field Order No. 15 granted 400,000 acres to freed people in January 1865. Andrew Johnson reversed the order and returned the land to former slaveholders. Freed people were evicted from land they had already begun farming.

The Consequence:

Without land or capital, freed people became sharecroppers, working the same land, for the same masters, in conditions barely better than slavery. The racial wealth gap that began with this betrayal persists today.

The Comparison:

Land reform has been essential to post-conflict justice worldwide. Japan's land reform after WWII broke feudal power structures. America chose to preserve them.

The Proposal:

Station federal troops in the South permanently to protect Black voters from terrorism. Make voting rights enforceable by federal courts, not dependent on Southern state governments.

What Actually Happened:

Federal troops were withdrawn in 1877 as part of the Hayes-Tilden compromise. The Supreme Court gutted enforcement in U.S. v. Cruikshank (1876). The Voting Rights Act of 1965 finally restored federal enforcement, 88 years later.

The Consequence:

Without federal protection, the Klan and Red Shirts terrorized Black voters into submission. Black voter registration in the South dropped from majorities to single digits. The 'Solid South' was built on murder.

The Comparison:

Germany has permanently banned Nazi symbols and parties. America withdrew troops and let white supremacists rebuild their power.

The Proposal:

The 14th Amendment barred Confederate officials from holding office. Enforce this permanently; never let traitors govern again.

What Actually Happened:

The Amnesty Act of 1872 restored voting and office-holding rights to nearly all former Confederates. By 1876, former Confederate officers held every Southern governorship.

The Consequence:

The men who led the rebellion became the men who wrote Jim Crow laws. Confederate General John Brown Gordon became Governor of Georgia. Confederate General Wade Hampton became Governor of South Carolina. Treason was rewarded with power.

The Comparison:

Denazification barred Nazi party members from government positions. America put Confederate generals back in charge of the states they had tried to destroy.

The Proposal:

Compensate freed people for 250 years of unpaid labor. The Confederacy's wealth was built on stolen work; justice requires restoration.

What Actually Happened:

No reparations were ever paid. Instead, some slaveholders received compensation for their 'lost property.' Freed people received nothing for generations of stolen labor.

The Consequence:

The racial wealth gap created by slavery was never addressed. In 1860, enslaved people represented $3.5 billion in 'assets,' more than all railroads, factories, and banks combined. That wealth remained with white families.

The Comparison:

After World War II, Germany paid reparations to Holocaust survivors and Israel. Japanese Americans received reparations for internment. Enslaved people and their descendants received nothing.

The Proposal:

Build public schools throughout the South. Educate freed people and poor whites together. Make education a federal guarantee.

What Actually Happened:

The Freedmen's Bureau built schools, but was defunded by 1872. Southern states created segregated school systems with vastly unequal funding. Many Black schools were burned by white mobs.

The Consequence:

Educational inequality persisted for a century. Brown v. Board (1954) found segregated schools 'inherently unequal,' but by then, generations had been denied education. Many communities are still fighting the same battle.

The Comparison:

Reconstruction briefly created interracial democracy and public education. Redemption destroyed both. We're still rebuilding what was stolen.

Every failure of Reconstruction was a choice. When Radical Republicans proposed accountability (trials, land, votes, exclusion, reparations, education), moderate Republicans and Democrats chose leniency. The result was a century of Jim Crow, a mythology of the Lost Cause, and a racial caste system that shapes America today. The question isn't whether Reconstruction was too radical. The question is whether it was radical enough.

The Manufacturers of Myth

Who Built the Lost Cause

The lie didn't spread itself. These are the people who invented, institutionalized, and spread it.

The man who literally named the mythology. Pollard was a Confederate newspaper editor who published 'The Lost Cause: A New Southern History of the War of the Confederates' in 1866, just one year after the war ended. He invented the framework that would dominate Southern memory for 150 years.

Contribution: Created the 'Lost Cause' term and narrative framework

Key Works:

The Lost Cause: A New Southern History of the War of the Confederates (1866)
Established the template: the war was about states' rights, not slavery; the South was noble and outnumbered; defeat was inevitable but honorable
The Lost Cause Regained (1868)
Argued the South could still 'win' through politics and controlling the narrative

"The Confederates have gone out of this war... with the proud, secret, dangerous consciousness that they are THE BETTER MEN, and that there was nothing wanting but a change of circumstances to make them the victors." The Lost Cause (1866)
Shows the mythology was designed from the start to preserve Southern identity and prepare for a 'rematch'

A Confederate general who never surrendered mentally. Early fled to Mexico rather than face capture, then returned to lead the Southern Historical Society, the organization that manufactured Confederate mythology as 'history.' He spent 30 years ensuring the South's version of events became the accepted narrative.

Contribution: Institutionalized Lost Cause mythology through the Southern Historical Society

Key Works:

Southern Historical Society Papers (1876-1959)
52 volumes of Confederate apologetics presented as 'scholarship,' still cited by Lost Cause believers today

"Our Southern people have generally been willing to accord to the North the preëminence in letters and science... But in the art of war... we think we may safely claim the superiority." Southern Historical Society Papers, Vol. 1
Shows Lost Cause was about preserving Southern superiority narrative

Tactics:

Collected and published Confederate officers' memoirs as 'primary sources'
Attacked any historian who attributed the war to slavery
Built the Robert E. Lee cult of personality
Blamed defeat on Longstreet (a convenient scapegoat who later became Republican)

The woman who put Lost Cause mythology into schoolchildren's heads. As Historian General of the United Daughters of the Confederacy (1911-1916), Rutherford led the campaign to control Southern textbooks. She published guidelines for 'acceptable' history and led boycotts against books that told the truth about slavery and the war.

Contribution: Weaponized education to spread Lost Cause mythology to generations of children

Key Works:

A Measuring Rod to Test Text Books and Reference Books in Schools, Colleges and Libraries (1919)
A checklist for censoring any textbook that portrayed slavery negatively or attributed secession to slavery
Truths of History (1920)
A compendium of Lost Cause talking points presented as 'facts' for teachers to use

"Reject a book that speaks of the Constitution as a compact between the States... Reject a text-book that... does not clearly outline the policy of the North in Reconstruction legislation and administration." A Measuring Rod (1919)
Explicit instructions to censor books that told the truth

"Reject a book that says the South fought to hold her slaves." A Measuring Rod (1919)
Direct command to suppress the documented cause of secession

Tactics:

Published 'approved' textbook lists distributed to schools across the South
Organized boycotts of publishers who printed accurate history
Pressured state legislatures to mandate Confederate-friendly curricula
Trained teachers in how to present Lost Cause as fact

The organization that built the physical and intellectual infrastructure of Lost Cause mythology. The UDC placed over 700 Confederate monuments, controlled Southern textbooks for decades, and created the rituals of Confederate memory. They didn't hide their purpose; they stated it openly.

Contribution: Monuments, textbooks, and cultural institutions spreading Lost Cause mythology

"To instill into the descendants of the people of the South a proper respect for and pride in the glorious war history." UDC founding charter, 1894
The explicit mission: make people proud of the Confederacy

Tactics:

Monument placement at courthouses, schools, and public squares, locations chosen for maximum visibility
Timing of monuments: during Jim Crow (1890s-1920s) and Civil Rights era (1950s-1960s), not memorials, but intimidation
Textbook campaigns using Rutherford's 'Measuring Rod'
Scholarships for students who wrote essays praising the Confederacy
'Confederate catechisms' teaching children Lost Cause as fact

Scale of Impact:

Monuments: Over 700 Confederate monuments, primarily 1890s-1920s and 1950s-1960s
Textbooks: Controlled Southern textbook selection for decades
Chapters: Over 800 chapters at peak membership

The academic who made Lost Cause mythology respectable in the North. Dunning trained a generation of historians, the 'Dunning School,' who portrayed Reconstruction as a tragic era of 'negro rule' and corruption. His students wrote the textbooks used nationwide, spreading Southern mythology into Northern classrooms.

Contribution: Academic legitimization of Lost Cause; trained historians who dominated the field for 50 years

Key Works:

Reconstruction, Political and Economic, 1865-1877 (1907)
Standard textbook for decades; portrayed Reconstruction as a disaster caused by giving Black people rights

"The negro had no pride of race and no aspirations or ideals save to be like the whites." Reconstruction, Political and Economic (1907)
Dunning's racism was explicit, and it shaped 'mainstream' history for generations

The filmmaker who brought Lost Cause mythology to mass audiences. 'The Birth of a Nation' (1915) portrayed the Klan as heroes, Black people as threats, and Reconstruction as a nightmare. It was the highest-grossing film of its era, screened at the White House, and directly led to the Klan's 20th-century revival.

Contribution: Mass media dissemination of Lost Cause mythology

Key Works:

The Birth of a Nation (1915)
Portrayed Klan as saviors of white civilization; directly sparked Klan revival; seen by millions

"The white men were roused by a mere instinct of self-preservation... until at last there had sprung into existence a great Ku Klux Klan, a veritable empire of the South, to protect the Southern country." Title card from 'The Birth of a Nation'
The Klan presented as heroes, and millions of Americans believed it

Impact:

President Woodrow Wilson screened it at the White House
Directly inspired the 1915 revival of the Ku Klux Klan
Highest-grossing film until 'Gone with the Wind'
Normalized Lost Cause mythology for Northern audiences

The Terror Campaign

The Massacres They Don't Teach

Reconstruction didn't fail. It was murdered. Here's the body count.

46 Black people killed

75+ wounded

91 homes, 4 churches, 8 schools burned

White mobs, including police and firefighters, attacked Black neighborhoods after a confrontation between white police and Black Union veterans. Over three days, they murdered 46 people, raped multiple Black women, and burned the Black community to the ground. No one was prosecuted.

Perpetrators: Memphis police, white civilians, Irish immigrants

Response: Congressional investigation led to the 14th Amendment and stricter Reconstruction policies

"The blacks had become rebellious, and the mob spirit seized upon the white population... They burned, plundered, robbed, and committed rape." Congressional Committee Report, 1866

34-50 killed (mostly Black)

Over 100 wounded

Convention hall attacked

Police and white mobs attacked a Louisiana Constitutional Convention that was debating Black voting rights. They murdered delegates and Black supporters in the streets. President Johnson blamed the victims. The massacre helped turn Northern opinion toward Radical Reconstruction.

Perpetrators: New Orleans police, white mobs, Confederate veterans

Response: Outrage in the North strengthened Radical Republicans in 1866 elections

"It was not a riot; it was an absolute massacre by the police... a murder which the mayor and police perpetrated without the shadow of necessity." General Philip Sheridan, U.S. Army

60-150 Black men murdered

Unknown

Courthouse burned with people inside

The bloodiest single act of Reconstruction violence. Black militia members defending the Grant Parish courthouse were overwhelmed by a white paramilitary force. After surrendering, prisoners were executed. Bodies were left unburied for weeks as a warning. The Supreme Court's ruling in the resulting case gutted federal civil rights enforcement.

Perpetrators: White League militia, Confederate veterans

Response: Supreme Court ruling in U.S. v. Cruikshank (1876) gutted the Enforcement Acts, making federal prosecution of racial violence nearly impossible

Legal Consequence: U.S. v. Cruikshank (1876) ruled the 14th Amendment only applied to STATE action, not private violence. The Klan could murder with impunity.

"The half of them was killed after the surrender... They were shot down like dogs." Survivor testimony to Congress

6 Black militia members executed after surrender

Multiple wounded

Black businesses looted

On America's centennial, Red Shirts militia attacked the Black militia of Hamburg. After the Black militia surrendered, five men were pulled from the group and executed one by one. The massacre launched the Red Shirts' campaign of terror that 'redeemed' South Carolina for white Democrats.

Perpetrators: Red Shirts militia, led by former Confederate general Matthew Butler

Response: Federal investigation, but no successful prosecutions; Butler was later elected U.S. Senator

"The leading white men of Edgefield have determined to seize the first opportunity that the negroes may offer them to provoke a riot and teach the negroes a lesson." Martin Gary, Red Shirts leader, planning the massacre

60-300+ Black residents killed

Unknown

Black newspaper burned, Black businesses destroyed

The only successful coup d'état in American history. Armed white supremacists overthrew the legitimately elected biracial city government of Wilmington. They murdered Black residents, burned the Black newspaper, and forced elected officials to resign at gunpoint. Black residents were driven from the city and never returned.

Perpetrators: Red Shirts, white business leaders, Democratic Party officials

Response: No federal intervention; perpetrators celebrated as heroes; North Carolina disenfranchised Black voters in 1900

"We will not live under these intolerable conditions. We will never surrender to a ragged raffle of negroes." Wilmington Declaration of White Independence, 1898

100-300+ Black residents killed

800+ wounded

35 blocks destroyed, 1,256 homes burned, 'Black Wall Street' annihilated

White mobs, including deputized civilians and possibly aircraft, attacked the prosperous Black neighborhood of Greenwood, known as 'Black Wall Street.' Over two days, they murdered hundreds, wounded thousands, and destroyed one of the wealthiest Black communities in America. No one was convicted. The massacre was erased from history for decades.

Perpetrators: White mobs, Tulsa police, deputized civilians, National Guard (some units)

Response: No prosecutions; survivors were arrested; insurance claims denied; massacre hidden from textbooks until 21st century

"When I got to the top of the hill, and could see down into Greenwood, all I could see was smoke and fire." Survivor testimony

100-237+ Black residents killed

Unknown

Multiple Black homes and churches burned

When Black sharecroppers organized a union to demand fair pay, white mobs and federal troops responded with a week of murder. Estimates range from 100 to over 800 dead. Black survivors were tortured into confessing to 'insurrection.' The massacre suppressed Black labor organizing for decades.

Perpetrators: White mobs, local police, U.S. Army troops

Response: 79 Black men arrested; 12 sentenced to death; NAACP legal fight reached Supreme Court (Moore v. Dempsey, 1923)

"We went out and hunted negroes all night." White participant, quoted in NAACP investigation

The Pattern

The Same 11 States

The 11 states that seceded in 1861 are the same 11 states that opposed civil rights in 1964, the same 11 states that vote Republican today, and the same 11 states with the most restrictive voting laws in 2024. This is not coincidence. This is inheritance. When Reconstruction failed, it failed specifically in these states, and the failure was never corrected.

Continue Exploring

More to Discover

The Full Story Party Realignment Voting Access Today Bingo Card

The Betrayal of Reconstruction

The Radical Republicans

What He Demanded:

What He Demanded:

What He Demanded:

What He Demanded:

What Should Have Happened

The Proposal:

What Actually Happened:

The Consequence:

The Comparison:

The Proposal:

What Actually Happened:

The Consequence:

The Comparison:

The Proposal:

What Actually Happened:

The Consequence:

The Comparison:

The Proposal:

What Actually Happened:

The Consequence:

The Comparison:

The Proposal:

What Actually Happened:

The Consequence:

The Comparison:

The Proposal:

What Actually Happened:

The Consequence:

The Comparison:

Who Built the Lost Cause

Key Works:

Key Works:

Tactics:

Key Works:

Tactics:

Tactics:

Scale of Impact:

Key Works:

Key Works:

Impact:

The Massacres They Don't Teach

The Same 11 States

More to Discover